How We Test VPN Services
By Tibor Moes / Updated: November 2024
How We Test VPN Services
At SoftwareLab.org, we are committed to helping you make informed decisions about your online privacy and security. Choosing the right VPN is crucial in today’s digital age, and our comprehensive testing methodology ensures that our recommendations are reliable, unbiased, and trustworthy. Here’s an inside look at how we test and review VPN providers.
Summary
To gauge the efficiency and effectiveness of VPN services, we’ve crafted a meticulous testing regimen based on nine core elements.
- Privacy – 25%
- Streaming – 15%
- Speed – 15%
- Security – 15%
- Server Locations – 10%
- User Experience – 10%
- Torrenting – 5%
- Device Compatibility – 5%
- Additional Features – 5%
Don’t become a victim of cybercrime. Protect your devices with the best antivirus software and your privacy with the best VPN service.
Independence and Transparency
Our reviews are grounded in objectivity and trust. To maintain independence:
- Self-Funded Testing: We personally subscribe to and pay for every VPN service we test. This eliminates any external influence on our evaluations.
- No Paid Reviews: We do not accept payments from VPN providers for reviews, rankings, or promotions. Instead, we rely on support from our readers to maintain transparency and integrity.
Our readers’ trust is our most valuable asset, and we work diligently to uphold it by providing honest, unbiased insights.
Rigorous Research and Testing
We combine real-world testing with in-depth research to evaluate each VPN across multiple critical areas.
- Speed Tests
Using multiple servers, we measure download and upload speeds to assess performance during activities like streaming, downloading, and browsing. - Security Checks
Employing tools like Wireshark, we analyze encryption protocols and look for potential vulnerabilities, ensuring your data stays safe from prying eyes. - Device Compatibility
From desktops to smartphones, we test VPN performance on various operating systems and devices to ensure seamless functionality everywhere.
Standardized Testing Environment
Consistency is key to fair and accurate results. Here’s how we level the playing field for every VPN we test:
- Uniform Hardware and Software: We use standardized systems and configurations.
- Fixed Location: All tests are conducted from the same geographic location to control environmental factors.
- Isolated Testing: By running tests on independent virtual machines, we avoid interference from other software or settings.
This controlled environment ensures that the results are directly comparable across all VPN providers.
Evaluation Criteria: How We Rate VPNs
Our evaluation system is structured around nine key categories, each weighted to reflect its importance to overall VPN performance:
- Privacy (25%) We dive into logging policies to determine if and how your data is stored, aiming for services with strict no-logs policies.
- Streaming (15%) By testing access to geo-restricted content on platforms like Netflix and BBC iPlayer, we assess reliability and quality for streamers.
- Speed (15%) Fast and stable connections are essential for uninterrupted browsing, gaming, and downloading.
- Security (15%) Encryption protocols, kill switches, and leak protection are tested to ensure your data remains secure.
- Server Locations (10%) A diverse server network improves access to global content and enhances connectivity.
- User Experience (10%) We evaluate app design, intuitiveness, and ease of use to ensure smooth user experiences.
- Torrenting (5%) VPNs are tested for P2P support, download speeds, and reliability during torrenting.
- Device Compatibility (5%) From desktops to mobile devices and routers, we verify compatibility across platforms.
- Additional Features (5%) Bonus tools like split tunneling, ad blockers, and unique features are considered for added value.
Each VPN is scored across these categories, giving readers a clear and comprehensive view of its strengths and weaknesses.
Our Commitment to Transparency
Our structured, unbiased testing process ensures that our reviews are accurate and trustworthy. At SoftwareLab.org, we are dedicated to protecting your online privacy and security by guiding you to the best VPN for your needs.
With every review, we strive to empower you with knowledge, helping you navigate the complex world of VPNs with confidence.
Explore our latest VPN reviews and take control of your online privacy today.

Author: Tibor Moes
Founder & Chief Editor at SoftwareLab
Tibor has tested 28 antivirus programs and 25 VPN services, and holds a Cybersecurity Graduate Certificate from Stanford University.
He uses Norton to protect his devices, NordVPN for his privacy, and Proton for his passwords and email.