What is Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)? In-Depth Guide

By Tibor Moes / Updated: June 2023

What is Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)? In-Depth Guide

What is Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)?

In the age of digital connectivity, understanding cross-site request forgery (CSRF) is crucial. These attacks are an increasingly prevalent threat that can have disastrous consequences for individuals and organizations alike. In this blog post, we’ll unravel the mystery behind CSRF attacks, explore their impact, and provide actionable strategies for mitigating their risks.

Summary

  • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) tricks victims into performing unwanted actions on web applications where they’re authenticated, often without their knowledge.

  • CSRF can lead to unauthorized data modification, such as changing email addresses and passwords, or making transactions.

  • Protection involves using anti-CSRF tokens, implementing same-site cookies, and using modern web security features to verify request origins.

Don’t become a victim of cybercrime. Protect your devices with the best antivirus software and your privacy with the best VPN service.

Understanding Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)

Cross-site request forgery is a type of web security vulnerability that exploits the trust between a user’s browser and a web application to perform unauthorized actions. Attackers trick users into executing these actions on their behalf, often by crafting and sending a forged request from a different website that runs in the security context of any other user. CSRF tokens, or challenge tokens, serve as a hidden value in forms that change the state of the web app, making it more difficult for attackers to execute a successful CSRF attack.

The main difference between CSRF attacks and other common web vulnerabilities, such as cross-site scripting (XSS), lies in the nature of the attack. A CSRF attack is considered a “one-way” attack, meaning that it only exploits the trust between the user’s browser and the web application, while XSS is a “two-way” attack that requires the attacker to inject malicious code into a web page.

Therefore, understanding CSRF attacks is a crucial step in maintaining a secure online presence.

How CSRF Attacks Occur

CSRF attacks occur when attackers trick users into executing unsolicited requests through social engineering or malicious links. To make it appear as if the user sent the request, attackers exploit the fact that browsers automatically include cookies, used to verify the user’s identity, in the request. Social engineering plays a significant role in CSRF attacks, as attackers can fool users into executing undesirable actions by disguising the exploit URL as an ordinary link or image.

HTTP POST requests are often used in CSRF attacks because they are commonly employed for state-changing requests in applications, and the victim’s browser sends the desired values through the request body with a POST request. The only difference between GET and POST attacks in CSRF is their execution method, making both types of requests similarly vulnerable to exploitation.

CSRF vs. XSS

While CSRF and XSS attacks share some similarities, they are distinct types of web security vulnerabilities. One key difference is that a CSRF attack requires the user to be logged in to the application, while XSS does not. Moreover, CSRF defenses, such as anti-CSRF tokens, may not be as effective when a site is vulnerable to XSS, as an XSS vulnerability can give the attacker access to everything on the page, including any anti-CSRF token value.

The same origin policy, a security measure that prevents web pages from making requests to a domain other than the one that served the page, is crucial in defending against XSS attacks. However, this policy is not enabled by default and needs to be explicitly set to allow cross-origin requests. The Access-Control-Allow-Origin header serves this purpose, letting cross-origin requests from a different domain through.

The Impact of CSRF Attacks

A successful CSRF attack can have a wide range of consequences, from unauthorized transactions and compromised accounts to system vulnerabilities. Data theft, changed passwords and unauthorized fund transfers are all potential outcomes of these attacks. Damaged client relationships can also be a consequence. CSRF vulnerabilities can have a particularly devastating impact, leading to fraudulent financial transactions, account takeovers, and system vulnerabilities.

When a CSRF attack targets a user with higher privileges, such as an administrative account, the consequences can be even more severe. A successful attack on an administrative account can lead to a full-blown system compromise, as these accounts have the ability to send requests with a different level of authority.

Real-World Examples

CSRF attacks have affected major websites and applications in the past, demonstrating the severity of these security threats. For instance, the uTorrent vulnerability discovered in 2009, a CSRF flaw found in the eBay application in 2004, and instances of changing users’ passwords or email addresses, making purchases or subscriptions without their knowledge or consent.

The potential consequences of CSRF attacks highlight the importance of understanding and mitigating these threats. Financial loss, identity theft, and data breaches are just some of the risks posed by CSRF attacks, which can also allow unauthorized access to sensitive information such as passwords and credit card numbers.

Conditions for a Successful CSRF Attack

For a CSRF attack to take place, several conditions must be met. First, the request must be able to be executed over HTTP, with a predictable structure. Second, the browser must automatically include session information in the request, allowing the attacker to exploit the user’s authenticated session. Finally, vulnerable HTTP methods, such as GET and POST requests, must be involved in the attack.

By understanding these conditions, organizations can better prepare their defenses against CSRF attacks, preventing unauthorized actions from being executed on their web applications. Ensuring that requests are not predictable and that active user sessions are secure are key components in protecting against CSRF attacks.

CSRF Attack Techniques

Attackers use various techniques to deliver CSRF exploits, including email phishing, malicious links, and hidden forms. Some CSRF attack techniques include token synchronization, double-submitting cookies, same-site cookies, enabling user interaction, and custom headers for requests.

In addition, login CSRF can be prevented by creating pre-sessions and including tokens in login forms to ensure the request is legitimate. Understanding these attack techniques can help organizations develop effective defenses against CSRF attacks.

By employing token synchronization, double-submitting cookies, and same-site cookies, organizations can minimize the chances of CSRF attacks being successful. Furthermore, enabling user interaction, using custom headers for requests, and implementing login CSRF mitigation can bolster overall CSRF protection.

GET, POST, and Other Requests

Various types of HTTP requests can be exploited in CSRF attacks, including GET, POST, PUT, and DELETE requests. These requests can be used to execute actions on the victim’s behalf, without their knowledge or consent. As a result, it is crucial for organizations to ensure that their web applications are not vulnerable to these types of requests.

JavaScript can also be employed by attackers to execute CSRF attacks, as it can be embedded into an exploit to automate the process. This highlights the importance of securing web applications against not only vulnerable HTTP requests, but also against potential cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities that can facilitate CSRF attacks.

Preventing CSRF Attacks: Best Practices

One of the most effective strategies for defending against CSRF attacks is ensuring the unpredictability of each request. By implementing secure coding practices and utilizing CSRF tokens, organizations can significantly reduce the likelihood of their web applications falling victim to CSRF attacks. CSRF tokens are unpredictable and unique values generated by the application, which are sent to the client to verify requests.

A defense-in-depth approach is recommended for impeding possible CSRF attacks, which involves implementing multiple layers of security measures, such as token-based defenses, framework-specific solutions, and additional security measures like SameSite cookies, origin validation, and re-authentication. By adopting these best practices, organizations can effectively prevent CSRF attacks and maintain a secure online presence.

Token-Based Defenses

Token-based defenses are a crucial component of CSRF prevention, as they involve using unique, random tokens to verify user requests and ensure their validity. Anti-CSRF tokens serve as an additional layer of protection, providing a random token that is added to authenticated requests, making it more difficult for attackers to execute a successful CSRF attack.

The best practice for using anti-CSRF tokens in AJAX calls is to return the token to the server in a custom AJAX header. This defense works because only JavaScript can create custom headers, and the browser’s single origin policy (SOP) blocks cross-site JavaScript calls, preventing CSRF attacks from leveraging the token value.

Framework-Specific Solutions

Popular programming frameworks, such as Django and Laravel, offer built-in CSRF defenses that can help organizations secure their web applications against potential attacks. For example, Django employs a CSRF token to secure forms, pulling the token from a storage cookie and including it in the request. Laravel, on the other hand, uses the Axios HTTP library for JavaScript requests, providing an additional layer of CSRF protection.

By leveraging these framework-specific solutions, organizations can effectively mitigate the risks of CSRF attacks and enhance the overall security of their web applications. These built-in defenses can be combined with other CSRF prevention strategies, such as token-based defenses and additional security measures, to provide comprehensive protection against CSRF attacks.

Additional Security Measures

In addition to token-based defenses and framework-specific solutions, organizations can implement supplementary defenses to further enhance their CSRF protection. SameSite cookies, for instance, let the browser know when it’s acceptable to send cookies with cross-site requests. This helps prevent CSRF attacks by ensuring that the cookie used for authentication is only sent to the same domain that created the request.

Another valuable defense is origin validation, which checks the origin of a request to ensure it is coming from a reliable source. Additionally, re-authentication strategies, such as requiring users to provide a password, a one-time token, or passing a CAPTCHA, can help protect against CSRF attacks by ensuring that actions are only executed by genuine users.

Identifying and Testing for CSRF Vulnerabilities

Regular security testing is essential to identify and remediate potential CSRF vulnerabilities in web applications. By conducting thorough security tests, organizations can quickly detect and address any vulnerabilities, minimizing the risks associated with CSRF attacks. The best way for organizations to check for CSRF vulnerabilities is to run an automated web scan using a vulnerability scanner, such as the Acunetix vulnerability scanner, which has a specialized CSRF scanner module.

When searching for CSRF vulnerabilities, it is important to check the source code of the web application, try out different attack techniques, and use both manual and automated methods. Regular security testing can help organizations maintain a secure online presence by identifying and addressing potential CSRF vulnerabilities before they can be exploited by attackers.

Security Standards and Best Practices

Industry-standard security guidelines, such as NIST SP 800-53 and ISO 27001, provide organizations with a framework for maintaining a secure online presence. By adhering to these guidelines, organizations can ensure that their sensitive and confidential data is protected from potential threats, including CSRF attacks.

Some common security standards and best practices include using strong passwords, keeping software up to date, and implementing multi-factor authentication. By following these guidelines and adopting a defense-in-depth approach to CSRF prevention, organizations can effectively safeguard their web applications against CSRF attacks and other security threats.

Common CSRF Misconceptions and Ineffective Defenses

There are several misconceptions about CSRF prevention that can leave applications vulnerable to attack. For example, some people believe that simply relying on HTTP Referer header validation, using only client-side token storage, or assuming that CSRF tokens are infallible will protect them from CSRF attacks. However, these misconceptions do not provide sufficient security against CSRF attacks and can leave web applications vulnerable.

Ineffective defenses, such as not using CSRF tokens, using predictable token values, or not validating tokens on the server side, can also leave web applications at risk.

To effectively protect against CSRF attacks, it is crucial to adopt a defense-in-depth approach, combining multiple layers of security measures and adhering to industry-standard security guidelines.

Summary

In conclusion, understanding and preventing CSRF attacks is crucial in maintaining a secure online presence. By unraveling the mechanics behind these attacks, exploring their impact, and adopting effective prevention strategies, organizations can successfully mitigate the risks associated with CSRF attacks. It is essential to remain vigilant, regularly test for vulnerabilities, and implement a defense-in-depth approach to ensure the security of web applications. Armed with this knowledge, you can confidently navigate the digital landscape and safeguard your organization from the potential threats posed by CSRF attacks.

How to stay safe online:

  • Practice Strong Password Hygiene: Use a unique and complex password for each account. A password manager can help generate and store them. In addition, enable two-factor authentication (2FA) whenever available.
  • Invest in Your Safety: Buying the best antivirus for Windows 11 is key for your online security. A high-quality antivirus like Norton, McAfee, or Bitdefender will safeguard your PC from various online threats, including malware, ransomware, and spyware.
  • Be Wary of Phishing Attempts: Be cautious when receiving suspicious communications that ask for personal information. Legitimate businesses will never ask for sensitive details via email or text. Before clicking on any links, ensure the sender's authenticity.
  • Stay Informed. We cover a wide range of cybersecurity topics on our blog. And there are several credible sources offering threat reports and recommendations, such as NIST, CISA, FBI, ENISA, Symantec, Verizon, Cisco, Crowdstrike, and many more.

Happy surfing!

Frequently Asked Questions

Below are the most frequently asked questions.

What can a CSRF attack do?

A CSRF attack can be used to take control of a user’s account by taking advantage of authentication processes. Attackers can send malicious requests to a website from an authenticated user without the user’s knowledge, allowing them to perform unauthorized actions such as transferring funds, changing passwords, and stealing confidential data.

These malicious requests can be difficult to detect, as they appear to come from a legitimate user. To protect against CSRF attacks, websites should implement measures such as token-based authentication, which requires a token-based authentication.

What does CSRF protect against?

CSRF protects against malicious attackers tricking users into taking unintended actions on a website, such as sending sensitive data or deleting important information. By assigning each user session a unique token, the synchronizer token pattern ensures that these malicious actions can’t be taken without knowing the token – making them much harder to execute.

How does CSRF cookie work?

To protect against CSRF attacks, the server-side application generates a unique and unpredictable token in the form of a cookie. This token needs to be submitted in each request by the client for verification by the server, thus preventing a malicious user from making unauthorized requests.

Author: Tibor Moes

Author: Tibor Moes

Founder & Chief Editor at SoftwareLab

Tibor has tested 39 antivirus programs and 30 VPN services, and holds a Cybersecurity Graduate Certificate from Stanford University.

He uses Norton to protect his devices, CyberGhost for his privacy, and Dashlane for his passwords.

You can find him on LinkedIn or contact him here.